DESPITE DOOMSDAY TALK,
NEWSPAPERS POST STRONG PROFITS
PAPER SPUN INTO GOLD
By CHET BRIDGER
Warren Buffett may be souring on the newspaper business, but the old-line industry is still cranking out cash despite new competition from the Internet.
"Newspapers are a category that is very threatened by the Internet,"
Buffett said during Berkshire Hathaways annual meeting in April, according
to the Wall Street Journal.
Internet business models have an advantage over newspapers because they have
virtually no delivery cost, Buffett said. The new economy will dramatically
alter the newspaper industry in the not too distant future, said the legendary
investor who owns The Buffalo News.
But dont write off the entire industry yet. Buffetts own paper
made $35 million last year and the nations largest publishing companies
are enjoying higher advertising revenue and profits this year.
Knight-Ridder posted a $325 million profit for the first half of 2000,
a healthy 16 percent increase from $281 million during the same period last
year. Newspapers, which include the Miami Herald and the Philadelphia Inquirer,
carried the company.
Knight-Ridders newspaper division earned $357 million from January
to June, according to reports filed with the Securities Exchange Commission.
The companys Internet division lost $19 million and its "corporate"
division lost $13 million.
The red ink is deepening at Knight-Ridders online division, which lost
only $9 million during the first six months of 1999.
Ironically, the dot-com world appears to be aiding Knight-Ridders newspaper
profits. "Continued strong demand from high-tech, dot-com and telecommunications"
companies helped general advertising revenue jump nearly 13 percent, the
company reported.
Classified revenue was also up 7 percent, primarily because of heavy recruitment
advertising at the San Jose Mercury News and other K-R papers.
Gannett has posted similar results this year, with profits soaring through
no thanks to the online division. Gannett earned $1.2 billion during the
first six months, a 167 percent jump from $455 million during the same period
in 1999.
The publisher of USA Today, the Rochester Democrat & Chronicle and numerous
other papers did not release its profits by operating division in recent
SEC filings. But Gannett also has a very large broadcasting division.
The Arlington, Va.-based corporation did report growing red ink from Internet
operations. The company posted 42 percent higher revenue, which reached $11
million, during the six month period.
"But expenses rose faster because of additional employee expenses and development
expenses to staff and promote the sites, " Gannett said in its SEC filings.
Online expenses at Gannett rose by 73 percent to $22 million for January
through June of this year.
The newspaper industry giants do not have the only content-based Web sites
struggling to make hay in the new economy. Space.com, the site founded by
former CNN business anchor Lou Dobbs, recently laid off one-fifth of its
staff, 22 job cuts, during a restructuring.
MTVi, the online arm of Viacom Inc,s MTV, recently postponed its plans
for an initial public offering and laid off 105 people. Some lesser profile
content sites shut down during the third quarter.
The mood of many industry executives was far from gloom and doom when they
gathered for the Newspapers 2000 convention this summer. Increased competition
from the Internet will force industry consolidation and squeeze profit margins,
but newspapers have more immediate problems, according to several publishers
quoted by the trade publication Editor & Publisher.
The newspaper business is hurting itself through poor marketing and compensation
packages ill suited to attracting and retaining talent in todays tight
labor markets, some industry leaders said.
"I think we have a very well-deserved image of not paying enough," said Alan
M. Horton, senior vice president of newspapers at the E. W. Scripps Co.
No public reports indicate Buffett making similar statements.